Biography & Early Wealth Journey
Moody left Evanescence in October 2003, only months after "Fallen" turned the band into an international sensation. Despite walking away from the group's subsequent albums and tours, he retained an extremely valuable songwriting catalog and built a successful second career writing and producing for other artists. His post-Evanescence credits include Kelly Clarkson's "Because of You," Avril Lavigne's "Nobody's Home," Daughtry's "What About Now," and work with Celine Dion, Halestorm, Lindsay Lohan, and others. Moody has also released solo albums and formed the band We Are the Fallen with several other former Evanescence musicians.
Early Life
Benjamin Robert Moody II was born on January 22, 1981, in Little Rock, Arkansas. He became interested in music at a young age and learned to play guitar, eventually developing an interest in songwriting and music production as well.
Moody's life changed in 1994 when he met Amy Lee at a Christian youth camp in Arkansas. Both were teenagers, and the two quickly discovered that they shared an interest in dramatic, emotionally intense music combining hard rock with piano, orchestral arrangements, and darker gothic influences.
Primary Income Streams & Multi-Million Contracts
They began writing songs together and recording homemade demos. Because they initially lacked a complete band, Moody and Lee sometimes performed as a duo at bookstores, coffeehouses, and other small venues around Little Rock.
Formation of Evanescence
Moody and Lee formed Evanescence during the mid-1990s. For much of the group's earliest period, Evanescence was essentially a songwriting and recording partnership between the two musicians rather than a conventional touring band.
They gradually developed an audience in Little Rock through independently distributed recordings and local radio exposure. Evanescence released its first self-titled EP in 1998, followed by another EP, "Sound Asleep," in 1999.
Trending Wealth Dossiers:
Real Estate, Luxury Assets & Personal Investments
In 2000, the group released the demo album "Origin." Only a limited number of legitimate copies were manufactured, making original editions highly sought-after collectibles after Evanescence later became famous.
The growing regional buzz eventually attracted the attention of Wind-up Records. Evanescence signed with the label and began developing its major-label debut.
Getty
"Fallen"
Evanescence released "Fallen" in March 2003. The album became one of the biggest rock debuts of its era, reaching #3 on the Billboard 200 and eventually selling more than 17 million copies worldwide.
Moody played guitar on the album and was deeply involved in its songwriting and production. He received a writing credit on all 11 tracks on the standard edition of "Fallen," generally alongside Amy Lee and, on many songs, keyboardist David Hodges.
The breakout single "Bring Me to Life" was written by Moody, Lee, and Hodges and featured guest vocals from Paul McCoy of 12 Stones. The song became an international hit after being featured on the soundtrack to the movie "Daredevil."
Other major singles included "Going Under," "My Immortal," and "Everybody's Fool."
At the 2004 Grammy Awards, Evanescence won Best New Artist and Best Hard Rock Performance for "Bring Me to Life." Moody, Lee, and Hodges were also nominated for Best Rock Song as the writers of "Bring Me to Life." Grammy records credit Moody with two wins and six nominations associated with his work during the "Fallen" era.
Leaving Evanescence
Despite the extraordinary success of "Fallen," the relationship between Moody and Lee had deteriorated badly.
On October 22, 2003, while Evanescence was touring Europe, Moody left the band. The split occurred only seven months after the release of "Fallen" and while the album was still climbing the charts around the world.
For years, the departure was broadly described as the result of creative differences. Moody later gave a much more detailed account, acknowledging that he and Lee had developed deeply conflicting ideas about Evanescence's future and that their once-close friendship had become hostile.
In a lengthy 2010 statement, Moody said he ultimately concluded that either he or Lee had to leave or Evanescence itself was unlikely to survive. He said he believed leaving was the correct decision, while also expressing regret over some of his behavior toward Lee during their conflicts.
Terry Balsamo replaced Moody as Evanescence's lead guitarist. Lee remained with the group and became its sole continuous member.
"Fallen" Royalties
Although Moody left Evanescence at the very beginning of the band's touring career, his participation in "Fallen" created a potentially significant long-term source of income.
As a credited songwriter across the entire album, Moody can earn publishing royalties when those compositions are streamed, sold, played on radio, performed publicly, licensed for television or movies, or otherwise commercially exploited.
That distinction is important when comparing Moody's career with Amy Lee's. Lee spent the following decades earning income from new Evanescence records, touring, merchandise, and later compositions that Moody does not share in. Moody, however, continues to participate financially in the enormously successful body of songs that the pair created together before his departure.
With more than 17 million copies sold worldwide, billions of streams generated across the Evanescence catalog, and songs such as "Bring Me to Life" and "My Immortal" continuing to receive widespread airplay and licensing, the "Fallen" publishing catalog remains an important component of Moody's wealth.
Songwriting and Producing After Evanescence
Moody quickly established himself as a songwriter and producer for other recording artists after leaving Evanescence.
One of his first major projects was working with Avril Lavigne on her 2004 album "Under My Skin." Moody co-wrote "Nobody's Home," which became one of the album's singles.
He then worked with Kelly Clarkson and fellow former Evanescence member David Hodges during the making of Clarkson's hugely successful album "Breakaway." Clarkson had originally written "Because of You" as a teenager, and Moody and Hodges helped her develop the song into its finished version. The three received songwriting credit, while Moody and Hodges also worked on production.
"Because of You" became one of Clarkson's signature songs and an international hit. BMI later named it the 2007 Pop Song of the Year after it generated more U.S. radio airplay during the eligibility period than any other song on BMI's list of the year's 50 most-performed songs.
Moody and Hodges also worked with Clarkson on "Addicted."
Avril Lavigne, Daughtry and Celine Dion
Moody's post-Evanescence songwriting catalog continued expanding during the remainder of the decade.
He co-wrote "What About Now" with David Hodges and Josh Hartzler. The song was recorded by Daughtry for the band's multi-platinum debut album and subsequently became a hit in its own right. Westlife later recorded a version of the song as well.
Moody also worked extensively on Celine Dion's 2007 album "Taking Chances." He co-wrote and produced "This Time" and served as a producer on Dion's recordings of "Alone" and "The Reason I Go On."
His other writing or production work has included projects involving Halestorm, Bo Bice, Hana Pestle, and Lindsay Lohan.
These songwriting and production credits provided Moody with an additional publishing catalog independent of the Evanescence songs that originally established his career.
"Everything Burns"
Moody also pursued a career as a recording artist after leaving Evanescence.
In 2005, he teamed with singer Anastacia on "Everything Burns," a song Moody wrote and produced for the soundtrack to the superhero film "Fantastic Four." Moody performed on the track alongside Anastacia and appeared in its music video.
Although it was not a major hit in the United States, "Everything Burns" performed well in several European markets and became one of Moody's most recognizable recordings outside Evanescence.
He also recorded "The End Has Come" for the soundtrack to the 2004 film "The Punisher."
Solo Albums
Moody released the "Mutiny Bootleg E.P." in 2008 before issuing his first full-length solo studio album, "All for This," in June 2009.
The album allowed Moody to explore material noticeably different from the dramatic hard rock sound associated with Evanescence.
He followed it with a second solo studio album, "You Can't Regret What You Don't Remember," in 2011. That record included a reworked version of "Everything Burns."
Moody's solo releases achieved only modest commercial success compared with his work for Evanescence and other artists, and he later joked about the comparatively tiny audience for his solo material.
We Are the Fallen
In 2009, Moody formed We Are the Fallen with former "American Idol" contestant Carly Smithson on vocals, former Evanescence musicians John LeCompt and Rocky Gray, and bassist Marty O'Brien.
Because Moody, LeCompt, and Gray all had connections to Evanescence and We Are the Fallen employed a similarly dramatic hard rock sound, comparisons between the two groups were inevitable.
Moody maintained that the project was not intended to compete with Evanescence and said he simply wanted to return to playing the style of music he enjoyed with musicians he liked.
We Are the Fallen signed with Universal Republic and released its debut album, "Tear the World Down," in 2010. The record debuted at #33 on the Billboard 200 after selling approximately 13,000 copies in its first week.
The band toured behind the album, including a 28-date run supporting HIM in the United States, but never released a second studio album and subsequently became inactive.
Other Projects
Moody later became involved with a project called The Halo Method alongside former Papa Roach drummer Dave Buckner and singer Lukas Rossi.
He has also worked in film. Moody appeared briefly as a zombie in the 2004 movie "Resident Evil: Apocalypse" and later appeared in the independent horror film "Dead and Gone." He also established a film and television production company called Makeshift Films.
Despite spending relatively little time as a member of Evanescence after the band's mainstream breakthrough, Moody's early work with Amy Lee has remained the defining commercial achievement of his career. His unusual financial legacy comes from having left one of the most successful rock acts of the 2000s almost immediately after its breakthrough while retaining songwriting interests in the album and songs that made it famous.
Moody
Lee